The choice for replacement skipper appears to rest between Steve Smith — who was stripped of the armband after the Sandpaper-gate ball-tampering scandal — and paceman Pat Cummins.
Cricket Australia said that Cummins, Paine’s vice-captain, “looks set to become the first fast bowler to captain the Test side in 65 years”.
But respected Indian cricket commentator Harsha Bhogle said Cummins’ workload meant Smith would likely get the nod, despite his tainted record.
“I suspect Australia will have to go back to Steve Smith as captain,” Bhogle tweeted.
I suspect Australia will have to go back to Steve Smith as captain. Pat Cummins would be a deserving candidate but… https://t.co/8OWROoys7y
— Harsha Bhogle (@bhogleharsha) 1637294774000
“Pat Cummins would be a deserving candidate but as a large-hearted fast bowler who gives every spell everything he has, and plays all three formats, his workload will need to be managed.”
Australian commentator Gerard Whateley said Paine’s sudden, tearful departure would “sit extremely heavily over Australian cricket going into the Ashes”.
“There will be a national sense of shock and trying to take it in and comprehend it, and then to forecast what happens next, it’s extraordinarily difficult to take in,” he told SEN radio.
England captain Joe Root faces his own issues, with calls for him to address the issue of racism in English cricket. The tourists are currently at a training camp in Queensland.
“Keep in mind England cricket is in a full-blown crisis at the moment with the racism scandal that has been unearthed and their captain is not untouched by that,” Whateley said.
He was “stunned” at the revelations involving Paine.
“It runs completely counter to the manner in which Tim has always conducted himself in the public sphere — he has been a tremendously dignified and respectful captain,” he said.